The Truth Test: What "Good Will Hunting" Teaches Us About Authentic Hiring

Help us improve our Daily Coach stories on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Listen to an episode, rate it, comment or email us your feedback!

In the film Good Will Hunting, the character Will Hunting—portrayed by Matt Damon—demonstrates his extraordinary memory and authenticity during a pivotal scene with Skylar his girlfriend, played by Minnie Driver. This moment reveals not only the brilliance of Will’s mind but also the depth and complexity of his character.

Will, a janitor at MIT with exceptional mathematical abilities, carries a tumultuous past filled with trauma and personal struggle. Despite his genius, his life is riddled with challenges that block his potential. The story begins to unfold when Professor Gerald Lambeau discovers Will’s anonymous solution to a complex math problem and attempts to steer him toward a brighter future. But Will’s violent tendencies and legal troubles prompt Lambeau to enlist the help of therapist Sean Maguire—brought to life by the late Robin Williams.

Through their sessions, Sean helps Will confront his pain, peel back his emotional armor, and begin to recognize his worth beyond intellect.

One scene in particular stands out.

During a conversation with Skylar, Will casually mentions that he has twelve big brothers. Taken aback, she challenges him to name them all. Without hesitation, Will rattles off all twelve names. Still skeptical, Skylar demands he do it again—immediately. Once more, Will delivers, flawlessly.

What seems like a charming exchange between two characters actually reveals something deeper: a powerful technique for assessing authenticity.

Skylar’s method—asking for immediate repetition—functions like a real-time integrity check. It gauges not just memory, but truthfulness. And it holds practical value beyond the screen, particularly in high-stakes environments like hiring and leadership evaluation.

In today’s workplace, authenticity is more than a buzzword. It’s a competitive advantage. Hiring authentic individuals—those who are not only qualified but aligned with a team’s values—can build trust, elevate culture, and boost long-term performance.

But how do we spot authenticity in an interview? Here are three practical techniques:

1. Behavioral Interviews

Behavioral interviews prompt candidates to share real-life examples of how they’ve navigated past situations. These questions help uncover core values like honesty, resilience, and teamwork.

Examples:

• “Tell me about a time you faced an ethical dilemma at work. How did you handle it?”

• “Describe a moment when you had to give honest feedback to a colleague. What was the outcome?”

These aren’t just prompts—they're truth-seeking tools.

2. The Immediate Repetition Technique

Inspired by Good Will Hunting, this approach involves asking a candidate to repeat or restate key information from earlier in the interview. For example, if someone says they led a major initiative, ask them to summarize the same project details again later.

Consistency often reveals character. The ability to retell without major variation suggests credibility—and genuine experience.

3. Values Alignment Checks

Does the candidate live out your organization's values?

Use situational judgment tests or real-life scenarios that reflect your team’s culture. Ask:

• “Here’s a core value we live by—can you share how you’ve embodied this in a past role?”

• “What part of our mission statement most resonates with you—and why?”

These questions push past surface-level responses and move into alignment and fit.

We’ve all been fooled before. We’ve all wanted to believe someone was who they claimed to be—only to find out later that they weren’t.

But by leaning into tools like behavioral interviewing, values alignment, and yes—even repetition—we can better navigate the tough terrain of hiring and surround ourselves with people who are not only smart and skilled, but real.

Because in leadership, in sports, in business, and in life—authenticity always endures.

…

Let us know what you think...

…

Did someone forward this to you? Subscribe for free here and get daily emails like this directly in your inbox.

Is there a story or theme you'd like to see The Daily Coach dive into this year? We'd love to hear your ideas here.